ISSN 2410-3594
e-ISSN 2786-7382
UDC 34; 159.9
Scientific Journal of the National Academy of Internal Affairs
- criminal offence; criminal liability; international legal act; martial law; natural environment; mineral resources; subsoil
- https://doi.org/10.63341/naia-herald/3.2025.33
- Pages 33-42
The relevance of this work lies in the need for society and the state to recognise the reality of the threat to the environment, which is reflected in the areas of state environmental policy, the main principles of which are to ensure environmental safety in Ukraine, to improve its level in the exclusion zone, to ensure environmental balance and to ensure accountability for violations of environmental legislation. The aim of the article was to conduct a systematic analysis of environmental protection issues in light of the provisions of national and international criminal law doctrine, to identify its inconsistencies and contradictions, to provide scientifically sound recommendations, and to develop proposals for improving its application and eliminating the identified contradictions. The methodological basis of the study was a system of general and special methods, which includes systemic-structural, logical-dogmatic, formal-legal, and terminological methods. The shortcomings of criminal law protection of the environment have been identified and ways to overcome them have been proposed, namely: mechanisms for environmental protection at the national and international levels have been identified, problematic issues and inconsistencies that may arise at the legislative level during the formulation or improvement of the relevant criminal law prohibition have been outlined, norms that could lead to legal conflicts have been identified, and the need to strengthen the imperative nature of legislative norms in order to ensure guarantees of the right to a safe environment has been proven. The expediency of strengthening the link between the right to a safe environment and other human rights guaranteed by the Constitution of Ukraine was analysed. Conclusions were formulated in the field of improving legislation on liability for criminal offences against the environment, focusing on the need to take into account the implementation of guarantees of the right to a safe environment as an element not only of environmental but also of national security of the state, and specific directions for improving the current criminal legislation of Ukraine are proposed. Taking into account the provisions of international acts aimed at strengthening the effectiveness of criminal law protection of the environment, the expediency of using the principle of clarity in the formulation of legal terminology in legislative practice has been proven. The practical value of the work lies in the fact that the results of scientific research will contribute to the complete and correct qualification of the analysed acts by practitioners and compliance with the principle of justice in the implementation of criminal liability
References
[1] Babailova, L.M. (2025). Compensation for environmental damage in criminal proceedings: International experience. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University, 88(3), 123-127. doi: 10.24144/2307- 3322.2025.88.3.18.
[2] Bazov, O.V. (2023). Legal and institutional principles of environmental protection in the activities of international criminal justice. Bulletin of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 30(2), 88-107. doi: 10.31359/1993-0909-2023-30-2-88.
[3] Berdnik, I.V. (2019). Criminal law protection of water resources: Theoretical and applied principles. Kyiv: Dakor.
[4] Daft, S. (2019). Environmental destruction is a war crime, but itʼs almost impossible to fall foul of the laws. Retrieved from https://theconversation.com/environmentaldestruction-is-a-war-crime-but-its-almost-impossible-to-fall-foul-of-the-laws-121180.
[5] Dmitriev, Yu.Ye. (2024). International legal protection of the environment from criminal encroachments during armed conflicts. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University. Law Series, 3(81), 67-71. doi: 10.24144/2307-3322.2024.81.3.8.
[6] Dudorov, O.O., & Movchan, R.O. (2020). On the directions of improving the mechanism of criminal-legal environmental protection (for the note of the developers of the new Criminal Code of Ukraine). Bullet of the Criminal Law Association of Ukraine, 1(13), 92-125. doi: 10.21564/2311-9640.2020.13.204733.
[7] Environment Definition. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://surl.li/iafbyz.
[8] Explanatory dictionary of the Ukrainian language. (2020). Retrieved from https://surl.li/yonvly.
[9] Grushko, M.V. (2023). International legal support for the protection of the natural environment and the issue of liability for causing environmental damage in connection with the armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine. Academic Visions, 22. doi 10.5281/zenodo.10071974.
[10] Guiding Principles for the Protection of the Natural Environment in Armed Conflict. (1994). Retrieved from https://surli.cc/jonihq.
[11] Makarenko, O.Yu., Makarenko, N.A., Nazymko, O.V., Gromenko, Yu.O., & Nesterenko, O.Yu. (2021). Problematic issues of criminal prosecution for illegal mining. Scientific Bulletin of the National Mining University, 4, 139-144. doi: 10.33271/nvngu/2021-4/139.
[12] Marco, S.I. (2024). Certain issues of improving criminal law protection of legal relations in the environmental sphere. Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence, 1, 516-521. doi: 10.24144/2788-6018.2024.01.90.
[13] Matviychuk, V.K., & Olinyk, V.P. (2022). Theoretical and practical problems of criminal-legal protection of the sea from pollution, littering as a global, social and legal problem of our time. Kyiv: Lira-K Publishing House.
[14] Mostepaniuk, L.O., & Pavlovska, A.A. (2020). Analysis of the elements of the crime provided for in Article 240-1 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Bulletin of the Penitentiary Association of Ukraine, 2, 126- 133. doi: 10.34015/2523-4552.2020.2.12.
[15] Movchan, R.O., Dudorov, O.O., Kamensky, D.V., Vozniuk, A.A., & Babanina, V.V. (2022). Criminal liability for illegal mining: Analysis of legislative amendments. Scientific Bulletin of the National Mining University, 5, 116-121. doi: 10.33271/nvngu/2022-5/116.
[16] Mytrophanov, I.I. (2022). Criminal Offenses Against the Environment under the Draft Criminal Code of Ukraine. Legal Scientific Electronic Journal, 12, 375-379. doi: 10.32782/2524-0374/2022-12/88.
[17] Nigreieva, O.O. (2021). International crimes and erga omnes obligations in the context of international environmental protection. Rule of Law, 44, 139-147. doi: 10.18524/2411-2054.2021.44.245087.
[18] Orellana, M.A. (2005). Criminal punishment for environmental damage: Individual and state responsibility at a crossroad. Georgetown International Environmental Law, 17(4), 673-696.
[19] Pakhomi, S.K. (2024). International legal regulation of environmental protection during armed conflict. Kyiv Law Journal, 3, 238-242. doi: 10.32782/klj/2024.3.34.
[20] Pasyeka, O., & Vyshnevska, I. (2024). Compliance of criminal legislation of the EU and Ukraine in the field of combating human trafficking with the acquis communautaire. Social & Legal Studios, 7(4), 248- 259. doi: 10.32518/sals4.2024.248.
[21] Plant, G. (1992). Environmental protection and the law of war: A “Fifth Geneva” Convention on the Environment in Time of Armed Conflict. London: Belhaven Press.
[22] Radchenko, A.M., & Tkachenko, O.M. (2020). International legal support for environmental protection in settlements. Law. Human. Environment, 11(4), 53-59. doi: 10.31548/law2020.04.006.
[23] Sadova, T.S. (2022). Environmental protection during armed conflicts in the perspective of the adoption of the Fifth Geneva Convention. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University. Series Law, 73(1), 186- 190. doi: 10.24144/2307-3322.2022.73.30.
[24] Sadova, T.S. (2023). War crimes against the environment under international criminal law. (Doctoral dissertation, Odesa National University named after I. I. Mechnikov, Odesa, Ukraine).
[25] Schillinger, J., Özerol, G., Güven-Griemert, Ş., & Heldeweg, M. (2020). Water in war: Understanding the impacts of armed conflict on water resources and their management. WIREs Water. 7, article number e1480. doi: 10.1002/wat2.1480.
[26] Turlova, Yu.A. (2023). Law enforcement practice in combating organised forms of complicity in environmental crimes. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University, Law Series, 77(2), 191-198. doi: 10.24144/2307-3322.2023.77.2.33.
[27] Turyk, M. (2023). Environmental damage as a war crime – can Russia be punished for ecocide? Retrieved from https://lb.ua/blog/mykola_turyk/558050_ekologichna_shkoda_yak_viyskoviy.html.
[28] Vorobei, P.A., Matviychuk, V.K., Phelyk, V.I., Khar, I.O., & Matviychuk, O.V. (2022). Theoretical and practical problems of criminal law protection of water bodies and the sea. Kyiv State Enterprise “Express-Obʼyava”.
[29] Vronska, H. (2023). Russiaʼs full-scale invasion harms the environment not only of Ukraine, but also of all of Europe. Retrieved from https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pres-centr/news/1418573.
[30] Vynnyk, A., & Gazdaika-Vasylyshyn, I. (2023). Strengthening criminal liability for committing property and certain other off nd Legal Studios, 6(2), 9-16. doi: 10.32518/sals2.2023.09.
[31] Weinstein, T. (2005). Prosecuting attacks that destroy the environment: Environmental crimes or humanitarian atrocities? Georgetown International Environmental Law, 11(4), 697-722.